Makemkv read error workaround. When it does it's something about corrupt files.

Makemkv read error workaround I have had this work for me in the past, however its very unlikely and it may have just been confirmation bias as I still have 2 discs that have never been able to rip and I try with every new version of Nov 9, 2019 · With all due respect, I can say with near certainty that these types of issues do not seem to be due to damage on the disks. Post by MrVanx » Mon Jun 29, 2020 8:18 pm. Insert the disc. 3rd disc Often, MakeMKV leaves no message at all. If you're experiencing rip errors, please read here first! Qun Mang Posts: 6 Joined: Mon Dec 04, 2017 12:20 am. Rome Basilica and Uffizi Gallery in Florence. S. 14. Each box brings 3D + 4K versions , 3D one is already ripped and also glorious to watch. If I had to put my money on something, I'd say it's probably due to cheap hardware and optics in these drives. New unsupported form of protection or should I replace the discs? If you're experiencing rip errors, please read here first! Post The simple workaround is to copy all files from the disc to the hard drive manually, without MakeMKV running. If your disc is damaged in such a way that even a single bit isn’t clear, it will fail the entire rip. The ONLY reason for this error is inability of the drive to read the data from the disc. The reason it plays fine in your disc drive is because when your player comes across a part it can’t read, it will skip ahead to the part it can read. I highly recommend having a spare drive for test purposes. (A/V sync errors are different, I don't see them often so I've never run them down. Mar 22, 2024 · www. e. I've done well north of 50 rips, and I've seen this behavior over and over again - I don't think they're all damaged. When it does it's something about corrupt files. Apr 25, 2023 · I know this is a very common issue but I have read errors on a particular disc. Feb 27, 2023 · MakeMKV support forum. Part of troubleshooting is being able to test and eliminate possibilities. Using other methods suggested around the interwebs, Oct 5, 2014 · Is there any know workaround? i couldn't upload the log files, because: Select all. But you may need to dig up a DVD-only drive to read some of them. MakeMKV will only succeed if it can read every bit correctly. That's the thing about playing vs. This suggests trying to copy the files off the disc directly and then it goes on to say "there is a fast and simple way to convert such copy Aug 27, 2016 · If you see "device not ready" errors after a read or seek error, it can be because the drive cannot operate reliably at the speeds MakeMKV is capable of ripping. g. I'm not sure I can find the exact post, but here's what you do: Open the disc in your finder (mac) or explorer (windows). Jun 29, 2020 · This thread saved me, and I was able to recover the disk without any loss to the content. I don't have a standalone 4k player so I can't easily check the disk. Launch MakeMKV. Maybe I give HandBrake a chance. The ripping part of MakeMKV, as you've experienced works very different from other programs, which BTW, you haven't said what you're using for straight rips. 17. As it is now, it’s fairly easy to procure a drive and the software is free and updated regularly. I have a couple discs that look perfect but they just don’t read Hey folks, I get a lot of the errors indicating a bad disk (or bad drive, but I have 2 drives, sometimes it works on one and not the other). In Preferences->IO, you can increase the retry count. Feb 22, 2017 · Okay I got this working. 3rd disc Dec 18, 2019 · Any workaround for this? Top. I read the page related to this from the link in the GUI. Using other methods suggested around the interwebs, Dec 3, 2023 · I tried to rip the disk again but this time MakeMKV just throws all kinds of errors and stops. , the "skipping over errors" thing people keep asking be included in MakeMKV). I had a TON of problems with ripping this whole series, purchased on Amazon U. Player software is programmed to ignore bad sectors, and try to continue without them, which is why a disk could "play correctly", even if there is a problem with it. The dump file Often, MakeMKV leaves no message at all. Similarly, if you download a PCLOS *iso file, you need every single bit to be correct: there's no way to say "oh heck, that's close enough. Jun 13, 2023 · Many users have reported issues trying ripping DVDs in MakeMKV - DVDs won't load/open/read/recognize in MakeMKV, "no disc inserted" error, playlist Obfuscation/fake playlist, etc. Sometimes I'll get 10 disks in a row that look fine but won't rip on either drive. You could see that actually Leawo Blu-ray Ripper is much more powerful than MakeMKV in decrypting, ripping and converting Blu-ray/DVD movie files to Dec 22, 2022 · Often, MakeMKV leaves no message at all. From the "if you are experiencing errors" topic in the BD section: Proper disc cleaning: What did you use to "copy the data"? Did it report any errors? MakeMKV is designed to read directly from the Bluray, so you don't have to copy the BD to the local disk. Nothing you can do other than clean the disc and try again. Recovering from read errors in Linux Mar 11, 2025 · This creates (in the current directory) an image file called brimage which is a byte for byte copy of the blu ray disc at /dev/sr0 (which refers to your blu-ray drive device). But I still can't get it ripped. I'm trying to rip Season 2 of Mr Robot from the Oct 31, 2022 · Dump files relate to being able to even open the disc to begin the rip process. Re: Recovering from read errors in Linux. 16. Do you think that there is chance that MakeMKV wrote read errors to the file? Jul 20, 2022 · I had a TON of problems with ripping this whole series, purchased on Amazon U. Apr 24, 2024 · In any case, having more than one optical drive has been handy with my usage of MakeMKV. Jan 4, 2017 · (emphasis mine) "Succeed" can mean different things to different people. For a failed Blu-ray and DVD ripping, the drive that cannot read the key area of the disk can be the main reason. The workaround for this is to set your system clock back to a date before the expiration (e. It makes it impossible for the DVD ripper to calculate the Ripping/transcoding software is configured to give up after a certain number of read errors, so you might need to go lower level. It could be an issue with the disc, try ripping another 4k Blu-ray and see if it fails. 30 posts Previous; 1; 2; MrVanx Posts: 18 Joined: Mon Mar 23, 2015 9:52 pm. Woodstock Posts: 10535 The log shows a huge number of read errors. Post by Woodstock » Mon Jun 29, 2020 10:16 pm. If you succeed in this, there is a fast and simple way to convert such copy into encrypted MakeMKV backup that can be opened by MakeMKV later. There's definitely something wrong with the disc or the reader you have Feb 22, 2017 · They are dual layer discs. If you're experiencing rip errors, please read here first! How do I get it to read my disc? How do I know if it's valid errors or not? The standard advice is to try gently cleaning the disc. Jun 20, 2021 · There are usually two types of read errors: 1) the decryption key for the disc is unknown and you will need to submit a file dump; and 2) errors that are the result of a dirty or defective disc. This suggests trying to copy the files off the disc directly and then it goes on to say "there is a fast and simple way to convert such copy into encrypted MakeMKV backup that can be opened by MakeMKV later. Jul 17, 2020 · MakeMKV v1. I don’t have any other blu-ray drives unfortunately, or know anyone else with ones for pc, and honestly a new one would probably be out of my budget since they are decently expensive, let alone DVDFab, I’m doing this so I can put to use my old collection and save money on subscription services lol. ) IMHO MakeMKV should probably try to re-read the section of disc when it encounters a hash error, because it seems to come down to how the drive handles ripping a disc with minor dust or imperfections. I’ll try the trial version tomorrow though, thanks a lot, Jun 29, 2020 · www. Playing skips errors, while ripping doesn't. com MakeMKV support forum. It was able to read and open and rip using MKV ALL ten of the problem discs that my new internal blu-ray drive could not b/c it was saying "No disc inserted". MakeMKV Read Error Workaround. 27 posts Previous; 1; 2; MrVanx Posts: 18 Joined: Mon Mar 23, 2015 9:52 pm. Jan 17, 2023 · That's a read errors related to the disc or drive The usual steps are Clean the disc with a damp lint free microfiber cloth and dry with another Replace the disc Clean the drive by opening it and cleaning lasers with alcohol on something lint free cleaning discs are a Jan 3, 2024 · Part 4. I have a disk that is in perfect condition except there is a very visible divot on the disk. Hi, I know this is a very common issue but I have read errors on a particular disc. It's possibly a problematic disc, like dust, scratches, an outdated firmware/hardware, copy protection methods MakeMKV can't handle. New unsupported form of protection or should I replace the discs? If you're experiencing rip errors, please read here first! Post Jul 17, 2020 · MakeMKV v1. You might hear a glitch when playing, and see the spot when it actually does the skip, but the drive has not been asked to read-until-complete, which takes it offline for a bit. Sometimes I have to actually gently clean a disc. Discussion of advanced MakeMKV functionality, expert mode, conversion profiles. May not be a unique problem to MakeMKV though, because when I play these discs through Cyberlink media player, the menu has all episodes, but it will not play any of the episodes that MakeMKV can't read. The file brimage will contain zeros for those parts of the disk that ddrescue could not read. 3rd disc Jul 17, 2020 · MakeMKV v1. If this fails, there's not much you can do, as it probably means the disc is damaged and not readable to the degree needed to copy the data from it. Once you've done that you need to run the program as an administrator. Jun 14, 2021 · I think I have read that ddrescue can read past errors and I have used Makemkv on ISOs before so I know that works. And the Windows DVD player accepts errors, while MakeMKV won't. For me using alcohol has resolved almost all read issues I have had with disc read issues. php?f=1&t . I've seen there is a way to create an ISO and then open it in MakeMKV and create a file from that. 13 win(x64-release) started Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as C: Not seeing any rip errors there - It looks like it found a 13:20 "extra", Jan 17, 2023 · Often, MakeMKV leaves no message at all. This is often Players have built in error correction which can work around read errors in some cases and you'll never notice. Post by Qun Mang » Mon Dec 04, 2017 3:02 am. This is caused by a damaged disc, failing drive, or both. Nov 19, 2022 · MakeMKV v1. makemkv. 4 linux(x64-release) started I was afraid the minor scratched/potting or possible warping on the discs was giving them read errors, but it seems all is well. Though I haven't played the backups Eventually managed to get it to work using the VLC & run as admin workaround previously mentioned. I didn't post process that file. Jun 21, 2024 · I can play the blu ray just fine (in 2d) from my blu ray player (hooked to tv). December 25, 2019). From the "if you are experiencing errors" topic in the BD section: Discussion of advanced MakeMKV functionality, expert mode, conversion profiles. Apr 25, 2023 · Hi, I know this is a very common issue but I have read errors on a particular disc. Press the "backup" button. Essentially, the network drive is identified as being formatted as FAT32 for compatibility reasons. The most recent version of MakeMKV (1. An imaging tool like ddrescue can be used to try making a disc image on a hard drive, trying and retrying to read from the source disc as many times as you like. Do not "open" the disc with MakeMKV. From the "if you are experiencing errors" topic in the BD section: Whenever I get this ILLEGAL REQUEST message, I close MakeMKV, then run VLC from Videolan to open and begin playing the disk, just to get past the menu and start the main feature. New unsupported form of protection or should I replace the discs? If you're experiencing rip errors, please read here first! Post Feb 21, 2023 · Often, MakeMKV leaves no message at all. Using other methods suggested around the interwebs, Apr 5, 2025 · Welcome to MakeMKV beta. Ripping sees the problem at sector '946470912', and stops to get it correct. Just to preface, yes, I have read the guide on the makeMKV forums about read errors. Recovering from read errors in Linux Discussion of advanced MakeMKV functionality, expert mode, conversion profiles. I can successfully copy all the episodes off one layer, but MakeMKV doesn't even see the 2nd layer. Can not Rip DVDs or Blu-rays with MakeMKV . It will rip the extras only. Jun 29, 2020 · www. MakeMKV needs to be able to read each and every byte since it is making a 1:1 Dec 16, 2023 · Even a very thin layer of dust or the greasy plastic residue from cases can cause read errors. Doing so disables MakeMKV's ability to re-try reads on parts of the disk that might "copy" to the hard drive, but not actually be what was seen on the disk. From there you can put in your registration key (Help- May 19, 2019 · Follow up: I purchased a Dell DW316 USB DVD drive for around $30. 3rd disc Jun 29, 2020 · This thread saved me, and I was able to recover the disk without any loss to the content. Bad disc, dirty disc, scratches Same for me as well, disc plays just fine in DVD player, But trying to rip with MakeMKV all I get is read errors. " You do have options in MakeMKV under Preferences -> IO -> Read Retry Count to set a high value, Jan 2, 2017 · The simple workaround is to copy all files from the disc to the hard drive manually, without MakeMKV running. com/forum2/viewtopic. ripping. Then while it is playing, I open MakeMKV and tell it to open the same drive. Recovering from read errors in Linux. Also, Jan 30, 2018 · Sent Mike the dumps for 2 Glorious Documentaries recently released in Italy. I know I'm not the only one getting these issues. During ddrescue the same issues happened, 9 sectors and 400kb of data, and it was able to read the rest of the disk. New unsupported form of protection or should I replace the discs? If you're experiencing rip errors, please read here first! Post Discussion of advanced MakeMKV functionality, expert mode, conversion profiles. 24 posts Previous; 1; 2; MrVanx Posts: 18 Joined: Mon Mar 23, 2015 9:52 pm. MakeMKV is a format converter, otherwise called "transcoder". Copy all the files on the disc into a folder on your computer. Here is another thread to check out on the subject. Read error occurs if MakeMKV fails to read the data encrypted in a physical disk. I got one reply there saying to just read the post but IT DOES NOT HELP. The error code indicates the disc cannot be read therefore cannot be ripped. New unsupported form of protection or should I replace the discs? If you're experiencing rip errors, please read here first! Post Often, MakeMKV leaves no message at all. This may not be the case, but it is what the operating system answers when asked that question. One rare disc I own, I've let ddrescue work on it for a total of like 2 weeks, and gotten up to Jan 3, 2018 · No, you can't. Feb 23, 2021 · Then, you only need to wait for the conversion to complete. New unsupported form of protection or should I replace the discs? If you're experiencing rip errors, please read here first! Post Feb 26, 2018 · Now, in MakeMKV, do a File->Open files, and have MakeMKV open discatt. Sure hoping someone can help as I have no idea what to do. 25 posts Previous; 1; 2; MrVanx Posts: 18 Joined: Mon Mar 23, 2015 9:52 pm. 몇 주 전, 처음으로 산 블루레이 (손더게)도 오류 없이 전 디스크 리핑에 성공했기 때문에 오류에 대한 걱정을 전혀 하지 않았는데, Apr 5, 2025 · Read error. Using other methods suggested around the interwebs, Jun 4, 2023 · _It is not a visually perfect rip_ unless there are zero errors. Probably MORE than 1/2 of the discs initially had read errors, but I was able to clean the discs (sometimes it took more than one cleaning per disc), and eventually got all Feb 18, 2023 · Thanks. Dec 4, 2017 · www. Probably MORE than 1/2 of the discs initially had read errors, but I was able to clean the discs (sometimes it took more than one cleaning per disc), and eventually got all Mar 18, 2025 · Firmware date: 2120-05-07 09:35 Bus encryption flags: 17 Highest AACS version: 81 LibreDrive Information Status: Enabled Drive platform: MT1959 Firmware type: Patched (microcode access re-enabled) Firmware version: 1. Re: If you're experiencing rip errors, please read here firs. According to the MakeMkv website, it’s pretty much an indicator of either a bad eulynn34 • Read errors. In fact, MakeMKV generated a Apr 2, 2023 · MakeMKV is attempting to make a perfect copy of the data it is reading. 7) has a key that expired at the end of February 2020. What did you use to "copy the data"? Did it report any errors? MakeMKV is designed to read directly from the Bluray, so you don't have to copy the BD to the local disk. The error comes from Jan 2, 2017 · I've successfully ripped other blu ray disks that look much worse. In UHD 4K these are fantastic movies for the Art lovers. 27 posts Previous; 1; 2; MrVanx Posts: 18 Recovering from read errors in Linux. Without the key in place, the encryption won't allow you past the initial disc read and you won't be able to fully open the disc in MakeMKV. With that in mind, the common solution for this problem is to bypass MakeMKV by copying the Jun 13, 2023 · If you are encountering MakeMKV Scsi error such as ILLEGAL REQUEST: READ OF SCRAMBLED SECTOR, MEDIUM ERROR: L-EC UNCORRECTABLE ERROR, Apr 25, 2023 · Hi, I know this is a very common issue but I have read errors on a particular disc. There are 아래의 블루레이 리핑 리뷰*에서 썼듯이, 나는 makemkv 프로그램을 이용해서 블루레이를 리핑해왔다. Apr 2, 2023 · MakeMKV is attempting to make a perfect copy of the data it is reading. So that is a great and cheap workaround, it pays to have both a blu ray and a dvd red laser, as they seem to complement each other, and www. The reason Apr 15, 2024 · Part 2. To me, it would be "copied ALL FILES WITHOUT ERRORS". MakeMKV is your one-click solution to convert video that you own into free and patents-unencumbered format that can be played everywhere. dat . Full explanation here: http://makemkv. 2 win(x64-release) started Using direct disc access mode UNRECOVERED READ ERROR' occurred while reading 'DVD+R-DL MATSHITA DVD-RAM UJ890AS 1. It converts the video clips from proprietary (and usually encrypted) disc into a set of MKV files, preserving most information Often, MakeMKV leaves no message at all. Oct 21, 2005 · That’s wishful thinking. Jun 11, 2013 · Woodstock wrote:The problem is that the system call that MakeMKV uses to verify the space available is being told that the network drive can't handle files larger than 4GB. When I get a disc that doesn't work in my main drive, oftentimes I can put it in a different drive and MakeMKV will read it without complaint. Otherwise, the What did you use to "copy the data"? Did it report any errors? MakeMKV is designed to read directly from the Bluray, so you don't have to copy the BD to the local disk. It takes a while, but eventually it gets through it. If you want to perform a full backup, use the option at the top of the program. I've found that some drives just don't like some discs. Jan 17, 2023 · That's a read errors related to the disc or drive The usual steps are Clean the disc with a damp lint free microfiber cloth and dry with another Replace the disc Clean the drive by opening it and cleaning lasers with alcohol on something lint free cleaning discs are a Jan 30, 2023 · The simple workaround is to copy all files from the disc to the hard drive manually, without MakeMKV running. To others it might mean "managed to get through everything after several attempts to exclude things that wouldn't copy because they're damaged" (i. So, the first thing I always do with a problem disc is a good cleaning. You’ll almost never get an “all discs” program as the goalposts are constantly moving. Cleaning the disks will probably help. dat. The map file mapfile is a text file which lists the sections ddrescue failed to read. Thanks, but this log was from just today, using my new Dec 6, 2020 · I've had success in the past downloading and using different release versions of MakeMKV. From the "if you are experiencing errors" topic in the BD section: Jul 17, 2020 · Whenever I get this ILLEGAL REQUEST message, I close MakeMKV, then run VLC from Videolan to open and begin playing the disk, just to get past the menu and start the main feature. 02 DVD all regions: Yes BD raw data read: Yes BD raw metadata read: Yes Unrestricted read speed: Yes Disc Information Label: Black That's a read errors related to the disc or drive The usual steps are Clean the disc with a damp lint free microfiber cloth and dry with another Replace the disc Clean the drive by opening it and cleaning lasers with alcohol on something lint free cleaning discs are a joke don't use them After that replace the drive if none of that works Mar 22, 2024 · Discussion of advanced MakeMKV functionality, expert mode, conversion profiles. MakeMKV then has no problem. Dec 2, 2023 · Hi, I know this is a very common issue but I have read errors on a particular disc. My disk didn't have any visible scratches to me, but it would always have errors around the 47% mark. The main movie plays fine on my stand alone player but Makemkv fails with disk errors. Note: Mike noted that the drive you used to copy the files from the disk must be the same drive you use to do the encrypted backup to get discatt. Often, MakeMKV leaves no message at all. From the "if you are experiencing errors" topic in the BD section: Nov 23, 2022 · Discussion of advanced MakeMKV functionality, expert mode, conversion profiles. Sep 30, 2020 · More likely it is taking more than your configured number of retries to get valid data from some sector. 00 UJ58 012143' at offset '0' Title #1 declared length is 2:20:07 while its real length is 1:17:01 - assuming fake title Apr 30, 2020 · MakeMKV keeps erroring out - any other options for ripping? discussion on the TexAgs The Nerdery forum. MakeMKV v1. So it might be worth going back to the previous version and trying again. 8. Mar 8, 2014 · As long as the offset number increases, MakeMKV is making headway by making repeated requests to the drive to try to read the sector. New unsupported form of protection or should I replace the discs? If you're experiencing rip errors, please read here first! Post Aug 15, 2020 · Hey all. If you succeed in this, there is a fast and simple way to convert such copy into encrypted MakeMKV backup that can be opened by Discussion of advanced MakeMKV functionality, expert mode, conversion profiles. vwf diwmz lty mhf xnm cnfhe pycld mxrwc vfmemw czloixgq jyasy etp zcw nvjuw tblj